[chuck-users] record and play multiple LiSa objects on multiple channels

[Kassen]

Harald;

works correctly on all three versions, as you see also adc.chan(0) =>
> dac.chan(0) works .
>
>
Ok, so then it's a LiSa issue and hopefully Dan will have a moment to look
into it. I think Dan was experimenting with multi-channel looping and this
seems to be a side-effect of that.

I got confused when looking at sndbuf's code. lisa should be similar.
> How is the multichannel code supposed to work?
> LiSaMulti_tick didn't change from 1.2.1.3 to current, so the problem
> must be elsewhere.
>
>
Hmmmm. I think LiSa is quite independent of SndBuf and is instead based on a
Max/Msp tool.

somewhere would make a gain stereo. Note that only the 2, 2 and the
> UGen_Stereo make the difference.
> Also from my first impressions, LiSa, sndbuf etc. don't use UGen_Multi
> or UGen_Stereo. So for such things they seem to be missing features.
> I think, one problem is that the number of channels is an attribute of
> a type. Most things in chuck are dynamic, so making the number of
> channels fixed when creating the type object doesn't make sense to me.
>
>
Yes, that sounds sensible to me.

ok, the voices are a special thing, I didn't take them into account.
>

LiSa is really way more involved than the rest, more powerful but also a bit
more tricky to understand.


> C++'s polymorphic functions are often a problematic concept. Perhaps
> rateVoice would be a better name. Or e.g. my_lisa.voice(v).rate(2.0)
> would make it more clear.
>

Yes, but at the expense of uniformity. Personally I'm very much in favour of
keeping things uniform as that means there are less surprises and there is
less to learn. I can see how this would be a topic for debate though.

>
>
> btw. should I've written some of the low level developer topics to
> chuck-dev?
> I wrote it here, because chuck-dev seems to be dead.
> Where do the devs meet?
>
>
I feel all of this should be fine here. The dev-list is where the dev
discussion "should" go but for some reason it isn't. I don't know. :-)

 Yours,
Kas.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.cs.princeton.edu/pipermail/chuck-users/attachments/20110410/1aa58f93/attachment.htm>